FIFA 10 vs Pro Evo 2010 - LB's Verdict

Previously we questioned who would come out on top in the latest battle between the biggest football game franchises on the market. After having a play of both I am now ready to decide which side of the fence I will fall...

A little history - Fifa burst onto gaming consoles in late 1993 challenging the previous dominance of classics such as Sensible Soccer and Kick Off. It turned into a massive series, especially after Fifa 95 when official licences were used and Fifa's trademark presentation began. Over the years however Fifa has been accused and in my opinion guilty, of style over substance.

Pro Evolution Soccer, originally ISS Pro, was released originally in 1997. The series has gradually grown and evolved (excuse the pun) over the years and become critically acclaimed as the footballer's football game. There were limited official licences and the commentary and presentation were laughable at times, but the gameplay shone through.

So bringin us back up to date...I have mentioned before my massive disappointment of last year's edition of Pro Evolution Soccer. It was if anything a backward step when really a leap forward was needed to rejuvenate the series. Prior to Pro '09 I can say hand on heart that I hated Fifa with a passion and thought it wasn't worthy of lacing Pro's boots...or loading it's disc in the tray maybe. I am happy to say this year's Pro Evo 2010 is an improvement on last years rubbish, BUT, i'm sad to say not a massive improvement. The players still seem sluggish and some of the AI movement will drive you insane. It's main downfall though I believe is in underestimating the competition.

Last year Fifa grew up. It stepped out of the Hollywood starlight and decided to get it's boots muddy, resulting in a game with depth and the trademark gloss. The movement of the players and silky control felt just right, aside from the OTT sliding tackles at times but i'll allow that. The game just felt natural and I was ashamed to admit it at first but Fifa was now on top. After sampling this year's game it looks like they've tweaked it just enough to stay on top too, completing my conversion to the "dark side"! With closer on-the-ball control and the game being made a tad quicker, the slickness is still there.

Overall i'd have to say it's a no brainer and any die-hard Pro Evo fans need to wake up and smell the coffee (includin you Mr 2Drinks!). It almost hurts me to say it but Fifa is champ for another year.

FIFA 10 vs Pro Evo 2010

It's that time of year again, the new football season has kicked off and a debate that has raged for years continues...no it's not the one about how can Yakubu only be 22 still? It's FIFA vs PRO! This debate rarely leaves anyone sitting on the fence, you are one side or the other.

I have been a die-hard Pro Evolution Soccer fan since the beginning, it was always the footballer's football game. Maybe it didn't have the polish and flair in presentation of it's rival but as any true gamer knows, it's the gameplay that counts. Pro Evo has grown from underdog to top dog gradually....until last year...

Last year's 2009 release saw a major shift in gameplay and when I say major shift I mean in a backwards direction. So much so I put on a disguise so nobody would recognise me and rented FIFA. I was shocked, it couldn't be. I actually preferred FIFA. To me this was like being forced to eat custard and reluctantly liking it, so much so I wanted more.

This year i'm torn, for once it's not a no brainer, both will have to have serious consideration.

Which one will you buy?!